Almost every dog owner asks this at some point: should I walk my dog on a collar or a harness? Both have a place. The right choice depends on your dog's size, how much he pulls, and what you need from a walk.
What a collar does well
- It is the simplest way to carry ID tags, and many places require a collar with ID.
- It is quick to put on and comfortable to wear all day.
- It works well for dogs that already walk calmly on a loose leash.
The downside is where the force goes. When a dog pulls or lunges on a collar, the pressure lands on the front of the neck. For strong pullers, small breeds and flat-faced breeds, that is the part of the body you most want to protect.
What a harness does well
- Spreads pressure across the chest and back instead of the neck.
- Gives you more control, especially with a top handle you can grab at kerbs, vet visits or when another dog passes.
- Is harder to back out of than a loose collar when fitted properly.
- Can reduce pulling when it has a front clip at the chest, which turns your dog back toward you when he pulls.
Which should you choose?
Choose a harness if your dog pulls, is a small or flat-faced breed, is a puppy still learning leash manners, or rides in the car on a seat belt. Many vets recommend a harness for dogs that pull hard on walks.
A collar alone may be enough if your dog is an adult who reliably walks on a loose leash.
Many owners use both: a collar for ID tags, and a harness for the leash.
How to fit a harness
- Measure around the widest part of your dog's chest and check the size guide.
- You should be able to slide two fingers under any strap.
- The harness shouldn't rub behind the front legs or slide to one side when he moves.
Our pick
The PawForge Personalized Powerharness goes over the head with one buckle, has padded chest and back plates, a top handle and a reflective band, and comes with your dog's name printed on the side. Add the Front D-Ring Attachment if he pulls. Browse all dog harnesses.